Some people truly are talented writers and can write as well as if not better than AI. Sadly, I'm not one of them. You are a good writer, and some part of that is natural talent but practice makes perfect. I do think you're correct that no solution will ever make everyone happy. Personally if someone uses a little AI and is open about it and fully discloses it, why not? But this can't be like Splinterlands where you divide things into Modern (humans only) vs Wild (anything goes.) Another thing that will be sure to come along will be AI that analyzes your writing style and will replicate your style and look just like a human, that will make things really interesting.

There will never be a way to make us all happy, and the debate will be endless. But it doesn't mean it not worth having.