Gah, as soon as I heard the Killers it exploded in my head. Was a popular album when I was listening to the radio a lot and of course my boy was a teenager then. I heard a great acoustic version of All These Things that I've Done the other day - it was really beautiful!
I guess 2011, a gen x'er is going to be 30 - 40, so it might still be in their scope to remember a song like that - I still listened to a lot of new music back then.